This topic seems to come up every year with a variety of different opinions, pro and con. As the season has begun in several warmer states there have already been injuries resulting in pitchers being hospitalized due to being struck by a ball which was hit with a metal bat. At this time, Gunnar Sandberg, a 16-year-old Marin Catholic High School pitcher, lay in a medically induced coma after being hit in the head March 11 by a line drive off a metal bat during a scrimmage against De La Salle High School of Concord. Within 48 hours, doctors had removed a portion of Sandberg’s skull to relieve the pressure on his brain, where he remains today in critical but stable condition at Marin General Hospital. In past years, there have been several pitchers at all levels including college, who have been killed by baseballs hit off of metal bats.
There are experts and metal bat makers that say that there is no data to suggest that there is any significant safety risk when using metal bats. Most little league officials, support a ban on metal bats especially at the older ages. Some high school coaches support a switch to wooden bats but think that the cost associated with wooden bats will make it prohibitive. Wood bats cost less but they break more often and would require replacement more often. North Dakota and New York City have banned the use of metal bats for safety reasons. Other states think that it is just a known/accepted risk in the game so they haven’t banned the metal bats. There are also counties that require youth pitchers to where helmets.
As someone who has watched several games at all levels, I can clearly see a difference in the bounce a ball gets off of a metal bat vs a wood bat. I often pray for college pitchers as they seemingly have the biggest risk. In my eyes, these guys have absolutely no way to protect themselves from these 140 mph plus line drives that are hit up the middle.
It seems that more should be done in this area in terms of research by independent sources. It is apparent that there is a financial component to this conversation. Bat manufacturers and there suppliers have a vested interest in the result of this conversation therefore they need to be left out of the research. It’s hard to take a side on this issue without data to support it. As the summer goes on, this topic will heat up once again. Hopefully no one has to die again before we get to the facts around the issue.
Play Ball!
